54
Models Considered
25
Hours of Research
2
Researchers Consulted
85
Reviews Analyzed

Best Waterproof Eyeliners

When it comes to eyeliners, many women prefer waterproof. This is because you never know when you’re going to sweat, get caught in the rain, shed into tears, or even go swimming. When your makeup is waterproof, you can rest assured it won’t smudge or run when in contact with water. There will be no clumping or smearing, so you can avoid the appearance of crying. And while your eyeliner is waterproof, it can still be easily removed with the right products.

You will find so many brands of waterproof eyeliners out there, but not all are created equal. Some do not have a strong enough waterproofing formula that can guarantee a flawless eye makeup 24/7. Some can clump in the middle of the day, making them easier to rub off. Others start to lighten by midday, leaving you with a duller appearance. This is why it is important to choose your waterproof eyeliner wisely. We don’t want you to make the wrong choice of makeup, so our team of researchers reviewed various liners online to find the ones with the best waterproofing formula. Read on to see why many women are raving over our six top picks.

Buyers Guide

  1. Is waterproof eyeliner safe for the eyes?

    Answer: When applied properly, a waterproof liner is safe. Just be sure to use a liner that is formulated for your waterline. This way, it will not cause an infection.

  2. Can you use a waterproof eyeliner when you wear contacts?

    Answer: Applying waterproof eyeliner on your waterline when you are a contact lens wearer is not advisable. The makeup can block the oil glands of your eyelids.

  3. Are there risks in wearing a waterproof eyeliner?

    Answer: People with sensitive, sty-prone eyes run the risk contaminating their eye with a waterproof eyeliner. The makeup can cause irritation and vision issues, potentially causing damage.

Our Top Picks

#1

NYK Professional Makeup Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

  • Black
  • Long lasting
  • Precise tip
  • Broad and bold

Get dramatic, mystifying eyes with this waterproof eyeliner. It has an ultra-precise tip that is flexible and easy to use, so every stroke is unbelievably fluid for a defined finish. It is certified and acknowledged by PETA as a cruelty-free product. This eyeliner has a matte finish and vegan formula. Its tip allows you to control the thickness of your lines by pressing down with just a touch.

#2

Maybelline New York Tattoostudio Eyeliner Pencil Makeup

  • Waterproof
  • Long wearing
  • Deep onyx
  • 0.04 ounce

Achieve that beautiful evening look with this waterproof eyeliner. It draws on an ultra-precise line with a color intensity that can last for 36 hours. It features rich color pigments that deliver an intense eye definition. This long-lasting eyeliner glides on in 1 smooth stroke and achieves precise definition on the go. It effortlessly defines the lash line with a pigment-rich finish. It is waterproof with no smudging or fading.  

#3

Rimmel Exaggerate Eye Definer

  • Waterproof
  • Long lasting
  • Easy twist
  • Self-sharpening

Create beautiful dark lines with this waterproof eyeliner. It goes on smooth with a deep, rich color. It is soft textured and fine tipped for precise, long-wearing application. This eyeliner has an easy twist-up sharpener for convenient use. It compliments any eyeshadow, primer, mascara, or highlighter. It is available in 4 colors to define every look. Thanks to its smooth and creamy texture, this liner easily get dense with up to 10 hours of wear. It features a gel-like, shiny finish and retractable applicator.

#4

Mia Adora Premium Black Eyeliner

  • Micro-tip
  • Easy to use
  • Waterproof
  • Smudge-proof

Be ready for sexy eyes that smolder with this waterproof eyeliner. It has a high-precision felt tip to let you achieve both thin and thick lines. Its tip allows you to easily control the line to create your desired effect. This eyeliner has a fast-drying formula that ensures that it doesn’t smudge once applied. It is oil free, tear-proof, life-proof, and easy to glide. It is safe to use with your lash extensions and falsies. The liner is completely cruelty and paraben free.

#5

Covergirl Ink It! By Perfect Point Plus Waterproof Eyeliner

  • Black
  • 2 count
  • Self-sharpening
  • Glides on easily

Feel free to be yourself and go about your day with this waterproof eyeliner. It gives a pen-like precision that lasts for 12 hours. Its waterproof formula enhances your eyes with a bold color. This self-sharpening eyeliner glides on easily without skipping, dragging, or pulling. It has the perfect shade for any occasion and every mood. Its gel-like, smooth-glide formula won’t budge. Thanks to its smooth applicator, it gives expert control every single time. It lets you achieve defined eyes in just minutes.

#6

iMethod Eyeliner Stamp

  • 2 count
  • No dipping
  • For all eye shapes
  • Stays on all day

Ensure your eyes remain strikingly sultry all day with this waterproof eyeliner. It makes achieving the perfect cat eye possible for anyone, including those with hooded eyes. It comes with a cat flick stamp on 1 end and a fine liner on the other. This eyeliner is well inked and well pigmented which makes filling precise and easy. It is long lasting, waterproof, and smudge-proof. It does not need retouching throughout the day and evening. The symmetrical wing stamper creates perfectly symmetrical shapes. It includes 2 wing eyeliners: 1 for your left eye and the other for your right.

An expensive brand doesn’t always mean an effective product. You will find cheaper ones that have an exceptional staying power like these six waterproof eyeliners.