Models Considered
Hours of Research
Researchers Consulted
Reviews Analyzed

Best Pacifiers

It is common for infants to suck their thumb, but because they touch many objects throughout the day, their finger is the last thing you want inside their mouth. If you do remove their finger from their mouth, they look for other things to suck, like toys or clothing that can be full of germs. This is why many parents turn to pacifiers. Not only do they break a child’s thumb-sucking habit but they’re also usually made of medical-grade materials that are safe for the baby.

Choosing a pacifier, however, is not as easy as one may think. A good pacifier should respect the natural development of a baby’s teeth and gums, and support the natural palate development of an infant In order to do this, it should have a shape that conforms to a baby’s tongue and roof of mouth. We made the search for the perfect pacifier easier for you by reviewing several products on the market.

Buyers Guide

  1. What is a pacifier?

    Answer: Also known as a binky, soother, teether or Dodie, a pacifier is a rubber, plastic, or silicone nipple given to an infant to suck upon.

  2. Are pacifiers good for babies?

    Answer: Pacifiers can soothe a crying infant, reduce pain, help tube-fed babies learn to use a bottle, and reduce the risk of sudden infant death syndrome.

  3. When should a baby stop using a pacifier?

    Answer: Pediatric dentists recommend limiting pacifier time once a child is 2 and eliminating it by age 4 to avoid dental problems.

Our Top Picks


MAM Clear Pacifiers

  • Pack of 3
  • Calms and soothes
  • Symmetrical nipple
  • Suitable for infants 0 to 6 months old

Relax your little one with this set of 3 clear pacifiers. Designed by parents and medical experts, it feels just like a mother’s breast. With a symmetrical silicone nipple, it does not need to be constantly adjusted to sit properly in a baby’s mouth. The binky’s anti-slip texture helps it stay comfortably in the mouth, while its curved shield allows it to sit conveniently on an infant’s face. The textured surface and multiple small openings on the pacifier shield allow air to circulate and the baby’s skin to breathe.


Nuk Orthodontic Pacifier

  • Pack of 3
  • Suitable for infants 0 to 6 months old
  • Asymmetrical shape
  • Heart-shaped shield

Calm your bundle of joy with this set of 3 orthodontic pacifiers. Its asymmetrical shape with a scooped bottom is modeled after mom’s nipple so it won’t cause your infant any confusion. It is flat to allow for more room for a natural sucking motion, and it is slim to reduce pressure on a baby’s jaw and teeth. The binky is narrow to help prevent teeth misalignment, and its heart-shaped shield fits perfectly under a baby’s nose for easy breathing. The silicone nipples are BPA-free and top-rack dishwasher safe. One of the 3 pacifiers glow in the dark.


Philips Avent Ultra Air Pacifier

  • Pack of 2
  • Suitable for babies 6 to 18 months old
  • 98% nipple acceptance
  • Soft silicone nipple

Soothe your darling angel with this set of 2 pacifiers. It features 4 extra-large holes in the shield so your baby’s skin stays dry and is able to breathe. Its comfortable and soft silicone nipple feels just like a mom’s nipple, avoiding confusion. The binky’s shield is lightweight with rounded edges, providing a comfortable fit on an infant’s face. The nipple is collapsible with a symmetrical shape that respects a baby’s palate, teeth, and gums. Included is a carrying case that you can use to sterilize the pacifier in the microwave and store it hygienically.


Dr. Brown’s Advantage Pacifier

  • Pack of 2
  • With pacifier clip
  • Suitable for infants 0 to 6 months old
  • 100% silicone bulb

Help your baby relax with this set of 2 pacifiers. Its unique shield design reduces irritation by letting baby’s skin breathe, and its 100% silicone bulb features a rounded shape that satisfies suckling reflexes. It is fully symmetrical for reversible positioning, so it fits in your baby’s mouth either right-side up or upside down. The binky comes in 2 stages to fit developing faces. It is taste-free, odor-free, and BPA-free. It can be sterilized by boiling or through a microwave. The pacifier comes with a strong metal clasp to ensure it does not get lost or dropped.


Tommee Tippee Baby Pacifier

  • Pack of 2
  • Suitable for babies 6 to 18 months old
  • BPA free
  • Symmetrical shape

Put your baby at ease with this set of 2 pacifiers. Its orthodontic-shaped nipple has been designed to improve balance, making it easier for babies to hold the pacifier in their mouth. This symmetrical shape supports natural oral development, reducing pressure on a baby’s jaw and teeth. The nipple is reversible so it does not cause infants any confusion. The binky comes with a holder that is compatible with Moda soothers and any standard pacifier of most major brands.


Itzy Ritzy Soother Pacifier

  • Pack of 2
  • With air holes
  • 100% silicone
  • Safety tested

Give your baby peace of mind with this set of 2 pacifiers. Made of 100% food grade silicone, it is soft and durable, making it suitable for babies even when their teeth are coming in. It features 2 extra-large air holes for breathability. The pacifier is safety tested to meet ASTM safety standards and features a single-part design and collapsible handle for added safety. It is top-rack dishwasher safe and microwave steam sterilizer bag safe.

If feeding or rocking doesn’t do the trick to keep your baby from sucking their thumb, these pacifiers can be a helpful tool to have on hand. Because they are comfortable to suckle, they put a child at ease, making them the perfect distraction.