42
Models Considered
25
Hours of Research
3
Researchers Consulted
80
Reviews Analyzed

Best Eyeliner Pencils

When it comes to giving your eyes a dramatic look, an eyebrow pencil always does the trick. But not all liners are the same. By using the wrong pencil for your lids, your eyes can fall victim of smudging and smearing. A cheap eyeliner can create the illusion of raccoon eyes even after it has set. Even if it is waterproof, it doesn’t mean it won’t smudge. This is why it is important to choose your eye pencil wisely. Aside from defining your eyes, it should be able to stay on for hours without smearing off your eyes or running under it.

If you are looking for a good eyeliner pencil or simply want to replace your smudgy one, check out our top picks. Our team of researchers found six eyeliner pencils that create precise lines, are safe for the eyes, have a waterproof and smudge-proof formula, and are long-wearing. See why people are raving about these liners by reading on.

Buyers Guide

  1. What is an eyeliner pencil?

    Answer: An eyeliner is a makeup tool used to build a variety of different looks—from feathery wings to a sleek tight-lined eye. Its purpose is to enhance or even change the eye’s shape.

  2. How do you apply an eyeliner pencil?

    Answer: Using your eyeliner pencil, draw a line above upper lashes or below lower lashes or both, even on the water lines of the eyes.

  3. Can eyeliner pencils be used on eyebrows?

    Answer: Yes. You can line and define brows using an eyeliner pencil, then fill them in using eyeshadow or mascara.

Our Top Picks

#1

L’Oreal Paris Mechanical Pencil Eyeliner

  • With built-in sharpener
  • 7 shades to choose from
  • Smudge-proof
  • Rich and creamy

Achieve a bolder look with this mechanical eyeliner pencil. Its rich and creamy formulation allows it to glide on smoothly and stay put for up to 16 hours. It provides a long-lasting and fade-proof color to complement your overall look. The pencil has built-in sharpener for creating precise lines along the lash line, as well as a built-in smudger that creates a dramatic definition. It is suitable for sensitive eyes and comes in 7 shades: black, black-brown, brown, carbon black, navy, slate, and white.

#2

Nyx Professional Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil

  • 14 shades to choose from
  • Retractable
  • Smooth and smudge-proof
  • Cruelty free

Get defined and gorgeous eyes with this mechanical eyeliner pencil. Its intense pigment covers like a liquid eyeliner, while its creamy formula holds for hours. It is available in natural to bright shades, so you can achieve any look you want. There is no need for sharpening—just twist the pencil up and apply on your lids or brows. This smudge-proof beauty tool glides on effortlessly and lasts through heat and humidity without bleeding. It is PETA-certified cruelty free.

#3

Maybelline Unstoppable Eyeliner

  • Set of 2
  • Smudge resistant and waterproof
  • Easy to remove
  • Provides definition

Create any look you want with this eyeliner pencil. With a self-sharpening tip and a smudge-resistant waterproof formula, it delivers control and definition from natural lines to bold looks. It swivels up and down, so its point always stays sharp. Ophthalmologist tested, this pencil is suitable for those with sensitive eyes and who wear contact lenses. It stays on the waterline, works on oily skin, and can easily be removed with micellar water. Made fairly soft, this pencil goes on smoothly for a nice clean look.

#4

Rimmel Exaggerate Eye Definer

  • Self-sharpening
  • Waterproof
  • Twist-up design
  • Long lasting

Flaunt your sexy eyes with this eyeliner pencil. With a deep rich color, it gives you a dramatic look. Its soft, textured, and fine tip allows for precise, long-wearing application. The pencil has an easy twist-up design, which means there is no more need for a sharpener. Its formula gives you up to 10 hours of intact definition, so you can achieve a winged, smoky, or au naturale look. Included is a sharpener and smudging tool so you can have both subtly blended-in and striking lines.

#5

Burt’s Bees Nourishing Eyeliner

  • Easy application
  • With nourishing ingredients
  • Ophthalmologist tested
  • No parabens

Compliment your natural eye color with this eyeliner pencil. It is made with responsibly sourced cedar wood and 99.9% natural origin ingredients including jojoba, meadowfoam seed, and mango oil. It is specially formulated for delicate eye areas so you can be sure of a product that is safe for those with sensitive eyes and who wear contact lenses. This fadeproof and smear-resistant soft liner easily swipes onto the upper or lower lash lines for an instant pop of color, enhancing and defining the eyes. It is formulated without parabens, phthalates, SLS, petrolatum, talc, synthetic fragrances, and silicones. 

#6

Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil

  • With built-in sharpener
  • Waterproof
  • Available in 8 shades
  • Ophthalmologist tested

Add drama and definition to your eyes with this eyeliner pencil. Its ultra-silky and waterproof formula stays where it’s supposed to for up to 16 hours. It has a built-in sharpener on the opposite end to ensure a sharp tip that will let you create precise lines every single time. Because safety always matters, this pencil is ophthalmologist tested to ensure it is suitable for those with sensitive eyes and who wear contact lenses. With a built-in smudger, it allows you to blend and soften your lines for a smoldering, smoky look. 

These eyeliner pencils are the perfect solution for creating a dramatic look without the illusion of bands under the eyes. From soft definition to full-on smoky eyes, you can achieve that sultry look you desire.